We Are Hiring!

We are currently hiring Short Order Cooks, Sandwich Makers, and Cashiers!

Apply Now

Thanksgiving Pie Pickup

Pie Pickup is Wednesday, November 23rd, or Friday, November 25th, for Weekend Celebrations.

We wanted to say a HUGE THANK YOU for the overwhelming love and support this year. It was a record year for pie orders and we couldn’t be more grateful!

Welcome to Jonny C’s!

Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers is owned by Jon Cohen, a native of the New York City area who has owned and operated numerous delis and restaurants. Having been involved in the foodservice industry since the age of sixteen, he has incorporated many ideas and concepts into his Buffalo restaurants. Jonny C’s NY Deli in East Amherst opened in November of 2006.

Jonny C’s is located at 9350 Transit Road in East Amherst, New York right at the corner of Casey Road. It is a self-service deli featuring an eat-in dining room that is decorated with lots of New York City Nostalgia, with takeout being an available option as well. A wide variety of specialty meats and cold cuts are sold by the pound in addition to our extensive menu of delicious over-stuffed sandwiches, hot entrees, salads, side, and soups.

Order Online

New Menu Starts Oct. 24, 2022

Please read the menu as some of your favorites are gone and some of your favorites might have changed a bit.

Due to current market conditions we had to make these adjustments as we are experiencing supply chain issues, price increases beyond expectations due to inflation, and labor shortages.

We apologize in advance for this. Unfortunately, it is beyond our control.  

Thank you in advance for your continued support and patronage.

Jonny C’s 


November 21st – November 27th Weekly Specials


Wrap of the Week:
The Feast

Turkey, Stuffing, Gravy, Cranberry Sauce, and Melted Smoked Gouda all served in your choice of wrap.

Sweet of the Week:
Giant Cranberry Orange Muffins

Fresh Tart Cranberries and Orange Muffins topped with an orange glaze.

Sweet of the Week:
Pumpkin Cheesecake

Graham cracker crust, creamy pumpkin spice cheesecake filling, topped with whipped cream.

Counter Item of the Week:
Spiced Maple Pecan Cookies

Warm fall spices meet maple and pecans to make this cookie delicious. 


Jonny C’s: A Buffalo Catering Company You Can Count On

Hosting an event? Give yourself peace of mind and worry about one less thing when you take advantage of Jonny C’s premier catering services.

Jonny C’s offers catering services on and off the premises.

Learn More or Request Catering